Arrest orders vs Casanova, ex-BCDA directors issued

May 14, 2017

BAGUIO CITY – A Manila court has issued warrants of arrest recently against former Bases Conversion Development Authority president Arnel Paciano Casanova and seven BCDA directors for a libel suit filed by Camp John Hay Development Corporation president Robert John Sobrepena in 2012.
Acting presiding judge Maria Paz Reyes-Yson of the Regional Trial Court branch 54 of Manila, in a 12-page decision signed last March 30, found “probable cause to hold all cause for the offense of libel” and a warrant of arrest be issued against the eight BCDA officials.
Yson found probable cause that accused-movants committed the offense charged and should be held for trial and on April 10 issued the warrant of arrest against the seven BCDA officials who were likewise ordered to pay the P10,000 cash bond.
Sobrepena filed the libel case against Casanova and the seven directors for the publication of a notice in the Philippine Daily Inquirer on April 10, 2012 “with (the) intent of causing irreparable injury to the complainant’s (Sobrepena) reputation and standing” which were false and malicious.
The notice said that Sobrepena is the owner of Fil-Estate Corporation, and his Sobrepena group runs both the College Assurance Plan and the Metro Rail Transit Corporation. While the former failed to give the educational benefit of hundreds of thousands planholders, the latter owes more than P1billion to the Department of Transportation and Communication.
Named in the libel are: former Subic Bay Management Corporation president Felicito Payumo, Zorayda Amelia Alonzo, Teresita Desierto, Ma. Aurora Gotina-Garcia, Ferdinand Golez, Elmar Gomez and Maximo Sangil.
Desierto has already posted the P10,000 cash bond, exempting him from the warrant of arrest issued by Yson.
In Jan. 19 of that year, the seven accused, except Desierto, filed an omnibus motion for judicial determination of probable cause and for suspension of issuance of warrants of arrest saying that the notice is not defamatory.
They argued, “It is privilege for being a fair and commentary on matters of public interest.”
Casanova said that it was just one “in a series of harassment suits initiated against the acussed-movants for taking a serious stand and protecting the interests of the Government against CJHDevCo.”
Casanova and group further said that the publication in question was not malicious, arguing that for it to be malicious, “there must be positive proof that the questioned publication was issued with actual malicious or with the knowledge that it was false or in reckless disregard of whether it was false or not.”
In response, Sobrepena said accused-movants attempt to “reduce the case into a harassment suit, trivializing the issues and the circumstances surrounding it…”
It was also an attempt to “muddle the issues to shift the attention of the court to extraneous issues such as the alleged dismissal of the prosecution offices in Manila and Baguio City of the complaints against the accused.”
Sobrepena in countering that it is not libelous quoted Article 354 of the Revised Penal Code which states: Every defamatory imputation is presumed to be malicious, even if it be true, if no good intention and justifiable motive for making it is shown.”
Back in 2014, Sobrepena was issued a warrant of arrest by the Pasay Regional Trial Court Branch 119 in connection with the P1.15 billion estafa case filed against him by the Bases Conversion Development Authority (BCDA) wherein he immediately posted bail of P40,000.
The warrant ensued after the Department of Justice indicted Sobrepena for his failure to pay the BCDA for the rental of 247 hectares within the John Hay Special Economic Zone (JHSEZ).
Now that both parties got it even with warrants what is left now is still for all stakeholders to wait. Pigeon Lobien / ABN

RELATED POSTS

PHILIPPINES- CHINA PHOTO EXHIBIT

PHILIPPINES- CHINA PHOTO EXHIBIT

A series of photographs was unveiled at SM City Baguio last September 19, 2022. Chinese Embassy's Minister Counselor Wang Yulei, Mayor...

LATEST NEWS

130 FAMILIES EVACUATE BECAUSE OF “KARDING”

130 FAMILIES EVACUATE BECAUSE OF “KARDING”

BAGUIO CITY (September 26, 2022)—Typhoon "Karding" did not directly hit the highland Cordillera though some 139 families in four provinces sought refuge to safer grounds, the social welfare department said. In Abra, 47 families consisting of 156 individuals were...

5 DRUG PERSONALITIES HULI SA BUY-BUST SA BAGUIO, ABRA

CAMP DANGWA, Benguet -- Nahaharap ngayon sa kasong paglabag sa Republic Act 9165 o Comprehensive Dangerous Drugs Act of 2002 ang limang drug personalities matapos silang arestuhin sa magkahiwalay na buy-bust operation na isinagawa sa Baguio City at Abra noong...

PHILIPPINES- CHINA PHOTO EXHIBIT

PHILIPPINES- CHINA PHOTO EXHIBIT

A series of photographs was unveiled at SM City Baguio last September 19, 2022. Chinese Embassy's Minister Counselor Wang Yulei, Mayor Benjamin Magalong, SM Assistant Vice President of Operations SM North 1 Jansenn Pe and SM Mall Manager Rona Correa led the unveiling...

PANGASINAN MANGPATAUD ITI SALT CENTER PARA PANAGSIRARAK, PRODUKSION

LINGAYEN, Pangasinan -Asidegen a mangipasdek iti probinsia a gobierno ti Pangasinan iti maysa a salt center iti probinsia tapno mapasayaat iti panagsirarak ken kamaudiananna iti produksion iti asin nga isut naggapuanan iti nagan ti probinsia. Iti maysa nga interbiu...

LA UNION 121ST POLICE SERVICE ANNIVERSARY

LA UNION 121ST POLICE SERVICE ANNIVERSARY

Affirming the Provincial Government of La Union’s support to the Philippine National Police’s commitment in securing a peaceful and orderly province, Gov. Raphaelle Veronica “Rafy” Ortega-David graced the 121st Police Service Anniversary celebration of the La Union...

DEVELOPERS MEET, DISCUSS SOLUTIONS FOR THE COUNTRY’S HOUSING INDUSTRY

As of 2017 , housing backlog estimated at 6.7 million ; developers target building two million for 2022 Every Filipino family aspires owning a home. Years, the Subdivision and Housing Developers Association, Inc. (SHDA) has relentlessly been trying to make that dream...

FACE MASK BOLUNTARYO NA ANG PAGGAMIT SA BAGUIO

BAGUIO CITY – Sa mga naasiwa na sa paggamit ng facemask ay nagbigay na ng signal si Mayor Benjamin Magalong at ang city council sa pamamagitan ng naaprubahang resolusyon na puwede ng hindi mag face mask o’ boluntaryo na lamang ang paggamit nito sa mga outdoor setting...

ADOPTED SON

ADOPTED SON

Iginawad ng provincial government ng Kalinga ang mataas na pagkilala kay PNP Chief Gen.Rodolfo Azurin,Jr., bilang adopted son ng Kalinga at pinangalanang "Inchakas" sa kanyang pagbisita sa lalawigan noong Setyembre 15, Photo by Kalinga PPO/ABN

MANNALON TI ILOCOS NORTE AGAPIT MANIPUD RICE HYBRID PROJECT

SUIDAD TI LAOAG, Ilocos Norte-Dagiti mannalon a nalipaset iti maysa a 160- hectare hybrid rice cluster technology demonstration project sadiay Ilocos Norte ket agapiten iti mulada inton sumaruno a lawas. Ipalgak dagiti nadumaduma a teknolohia ti panangpataud iti bagas...

ARCHIVE

CONTACT US FOR YOUR ADVERTISEMENTS

MASTHEAD

Pin It on Pinterest